We stayed in Carob Tree Cottage for a very enjoyable week - it's one of 4 properties on Dario's estate, but none are close by so it feels private. Dario is the perfect host, and very friendly. Speaks excellent English, and also patient enough to let me practise my basic Italian! The cottage is small, but perfectly comfortable for 2 people. It's quite 'rustic' inside, but has everything you need. The patio/bbq area was lovely, and lots of welcome shade under the carob tree. We spent most evenings having dinner outside, with music playing quietly - bliss! The real 'plus' point, of course, is the beautiful sandy beach at the end of the pathway. It was never busy, certainly not on the weekdays. A few more people there at weekends, but never felt 'crowded'. Sun umbrellas, chairs, were all by the gate as you walked through to the beach and you just helped yourself. Small boats as well, but we didn't try those (was quite windy most days!). Cefalu is a lovely town - yes, touristy, but quite charming restaurants along the seafront. We had a lovely romantic meal on our last night at Kentia restaurant which has a terrace overlooking the sea - worth calling in to pre-book a table if you particularly want the terrace. We also visited Mount Etna - if you're not going to walk up to the top (we didn't - too hot!), then it's definitely worth taking the cable car plus the 4x4 jeeps to get as close to the top as you can (this was an extra €57 per person, but would be a shame not to experience it if you go all that way...).
Practical points - you are able to use the washing machine which is outside next to Dario's house, so you don't have to disturb the main house. Good WiFi signal from the cottage. Although it mentions satellite TV, there are no English channels (in case that's important to you!). 5 minutes easy drive to large supermarket, and also easy to drive into Cefalu - once if you go into the town, turn left down to the seafront, turn left, you'll see a huge car park which is €5 for the day - much easier than trying to park on the street.
All in all, an excellent value rental - not luxurious but definitely more than comfortable for the price. The kitchen is well equipped, although would have been useful to have an oven and/or microwave - but 3 gas rings was just about enough! BBQ outside made up for it. The shower in the bathroom is a bit basic - wetroom style, with just a curtain round you, and the floor got soaked every time! The weather during second week of September was just perfect - sunny, with a spectacular storm on one day. (It would really help if Dario were to put the names of the various houses on the main gate, as we only spotted it because of a 'to rent' sign with his mobile number on it, and we put two and two together!)